Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Well the original shorts claim to have already closed their position and as it went up I think people are probably jumping on that side of the bet as well. Short interest doesn't mean it's going to go up forever this thing is just moving up on ponzi energy not short math


CNBC reported Melvin Capital closed the shorts, and then it turned out they didn’t.

This is very likely criminal market manipulation, but I’d be surprised if it ends up with more than a slap on the wrist to anyone.

And ... at the time I wrote that, si/float was still more than 100%, so - no, they most definitely not. (Am on phone now, will check later)


The idea that the shorts are for sure going to pay a higher price is super misleading and is the fuel for this ponzi. Everyone already knows the value of Gamestop is a tiny fraction of its price, so even if some shorts have to close, others will open short positions. To the people who believe they won't be the bag holders because of high short interest, this basically means the stock will always go up, and when enough people realize that's not true, the party is over and the ones opening short positions or closing long positions recently will be the only ones walking away with actual money.


Yes, but that’s not more ponzi than e.g. Snapchat which expected to never make money in its filing. When you buy it, you expect to sell it to a bigger fool, or for a miracle. GameStop is the same; they are both doomed, and will be worth 0 sooner or later unless a miracle happens.

The only reasonable valuation for either is (assets-liabilities), or liquidation value. All other value is based on a belief something will happen. In GameStop, it’s the belief that there are buyers of last resort who would pay almost any price - which is likely true for some of the shorts. Whether it is 1% or 10% or 100% is what these people are betting on.

And the call from industry to pause trading to regroup against Reddit indicates it’s likely a lot more than 1%




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: