Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Reliance on the Maginot Line?


The Maginot Line held.

Germans in Czech tanks went around the end of it, through Belgium.


Which was the whole point of the Maginot line, to channel the German advance through Belgium where a defensive line was to be established, so it was a success. Everything else - reconnaissance, defence of a forrest thought impenetrable to mass formations, coordination, adaptability to the changing environment (the Germans pouring through the supposedly impenetrable forrest), officer competency, coordination between army and air force, and coordination with the British, were massive failures.


The Line was a necessary component of a defense. It just needed more, that was not done.

Without Czech armor, the invasion might have failed. Predicting the Germans would have the full resources of Czechoslovakia would require more prescience than we should demand.


Yes, so they were reliant on it. When they couldn't make use of if they were swiftly beaten.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: