Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

why don't you just use chatGPT? from what i know it's running GPT3.5 and it's not that different (at least in terms of code quality)


As someone writing my first meaningful react app, code quality from gpt4 is monstrously better than 3.5. With gpt 4 i can often paste entire components and get meaningful corrections/bug fixes/non-trivial refactors. 3.5 just does a loop of mistaken fixes while it runs out of context length.


When my 25 queries per 3 hours runs out I don't use openai at all. That's how bad chat gpt is in comparison to gpt4 in my use cases.


My biggest complaint is the speed. Watching it print out like 56k is pretty annoying when coding.


There's a massive difference in response quality in my experience.

For example, I asked 3.5 to find a bug in a lengthy piece of Javascript. It said it's hard to give a correct answer because it doesn't know what the HTML or CSS looks like.

GPT4 spotted the bug almost immediately (it didn't manage to fix it though).


In my experiments bard is weaker than 3.5, but if it wasn't, than I would prefer the fresh data of bard.


One area where I noticed Bard was clearly behind (at least without crafting a better prompt) is getting from half-working program to a running program then sometime even to a correct program (I was using Python).

With GPT 3.5 and 4, I was able to just paste in the error and it'd do the rest. Bard however tried to tell me what the error could be, and wouldn't do well even when asked to fix the code.

Even GPT 4 though, when asked to go from specs to tests + code, would get stuck in a loop of making one test pass only to make the other pass and vice versa. The program I tried to let it write was a query validator that can test whether a string matches a pattern that uses AND, OR and NOT.

It did well on parsing my specs into tests, but from there on it didn't go very well.


Bard uses PaLM 2 now, which is definitely better than GPT-3.5. The question is only whether it is better than GPT-4.


What is its training data cutoff date?


We don't know (both for previous model LaMDA and new model PaLM 2), but it is less important for Bard because Bard has access to live data from Google search.


It's quite a vast difference between GPT-3.5 and GPT-4




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: