Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yeah, exactly. I looked at Kagi last week (first time I had heard of it), when the $10/month plan was "only" 1,000 searches a month and "unlimited" was $25. While I think that I'll probably stay well within 1,000 searches, I'm also not sure, and it's just not something I want to have to worry about (it's ~33/day on average and I doubt I'll ever hit it, but still...)

One of the reasons I decided to skip Kagi for now.



Wouldn't today's change make you reconsider, because you now no longer have to worry about how much you search for $10/month, it's just unlimited?


It me!

I literally looked at Kagi like a week or two ago from a link here. I really liked it, and I've really been hating Google search more and more each day. But I concluded that 1000 searches felt too limiting, and $25 felt too expensive, so I passed hoping a price change would come at some point in the future.

And voila! Just signed up for $10 unlimited. Probably won't even use 1000/month, but psychologically it just feels so much better.


Same here. Looked at Kagi a while back, thought about paying for it, but 1000 searches per month was way too little, especially considering what actually eats into your quota: load more results? another search. Looking for an image, so you search and then switch to Images? two searches. etc.

But as soon as "unlimited" became something I could reasonably buy, I was in :D


Yes, I'll probably check it out and at least consider paying for it, depending on how much I like it (well, once I have a job and some disposable income...) $25/month seemed too much regardless; I don't know the economics behind it but that it's now adjusted to $10/month seems I was right.


I am not the gp but yes. I had the same concern last time I evaluated Kagi and now I expect to become a paying customer this weekend when I have some time to do all my reading and reconfigure my main devices.


> I am not the gp

what is GP?

(sorry, I am new to hackernews and don't yet know all the acronyms)


“grand parent” - it’s a way to reference the comment as opposed to user in a thread.

“OP” aka “Original Poster” is usually the first in a thread.

“PSA” aka “Please See Attached” references a link or attachment to the original post, and is used in the title of the first post, i.e, please look at this webpage I’ve linked to and let’s discuss it.

“TFA” aka “The Featured Article” is often used in the discussions and is the same object as the original poster referenced via PSA


Welcome! And thanks to comprev who has laid it all out above.


> it's ~33/day on average and I doubt I'll ever hit it

That's a bit misleading. If the search engine really is that good, you should use it more, and then all of a sudden you'll hit the cap. I probably don't search that much now but that's because it's not worth the trouble.


I just don’t search that much.

And I don’t want to think about how much I search.

Comically, the biggest problem I have with signing up since $10 isn’t that much is that I don’t want to have to log into kagi to prove my account. I search on my phone, work computers, random terminals, etc etc. Having to userid and password to all these places disrupts my current UX of 1) open browser, 2) type search (maybe go to ddg.com first).

Changing to 1) open browser, 2) log into kagi, 3) search increases my time by 100x

I usually use the same browser, but I use incognito or fresh browsers at least once or twice a day.


They have a solution for that, a session link. They pass a token through a query parameter that validates to your account. You set that as the default search engine for each browser, no need to repeatedly sign in.

https://kagi.com/search?token=<some-token>


> If the search engine really is that good, you should use it more, and then all of a sudden you'll hit the cap.

FWIW, I searched less with Kagi, mostly because I needed fewer tries ;)


> If the search engine really is that good, you should use it more

In practice the opposite happens. Because Kagi is presumeably so good, people use it less, because they find stuff faster. Something that would require 2-3 searches on Google is just one search on Kagi.

Anecdotal evidence: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37008132


Well you should worry! I've heard that when people pass their search limit, the Kagi team shows up with big pick-up trucks to their front yard and start screaming insults, waking neighbours.

But seriously, I've seen this comment so many times now, that I'm curious: What is it that you worry about exactly?


I didn't post that comment, but I'd suggest it's not necessarily a rational worry at all. It's just human nature that if you tell somebody that something can run out, then some part of their brain will worry about it running out. :)


You can set notifications and hard limits. I had this reservation and 6 weeks in have gone to the $10 plan and have other family members liking not, so will likely upsize again.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: