Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

“Every community owns and controls the means of production upon which they depend for their survival.”

Such a system does not exist.

Your obvious point, that individual authors can publish their work freely, does little to change the system that requires government enforced punishment for people who would copy and share information available to them. But it would be unethical to pull the rug out from under authors who depend on that system today, so as I see it the best course of action is to make that system unnecessary through community support of all people, and the only ethical way I see to create that is by community ownership of the means of production.

> If you don’t reward great effort, virtually nobody provides it.

I strongly believe this is false and nonsense. This is propaganda from people who benefit from the system that rewards owners of capital who fear community ownership of the means of production.



>This is propaganda from people who benefit from the system that rewards owners of capital who fear community ownership of the means of production.

The Capitalist System does not imply restrictions on community ownership of the means of production. And I believe you are here not trying to appeal to a system that is completely ok with community ownership, you are trying to appeal to a system that restricts or completely bans private property on the means of production.

The problems with such systems are that they always end up with Famine and Gulags - because community ownership work and managed way worse, but the government gets all the power ower the whole economy and use it to remain in the power no matter the results




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: