Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


> the guy who has been at the bleeding edge of technology for the last two decades

In what way does working on the bleeding edge of technology qualify someone to make sweeping decisions in a completely unrelated problem domain? Especially when those decisions impact literally the entire world?


Why is he making any decisions? He's not a confirmed cabinet appointment.


That's a fun fantasy to entertain but his actions over the last few years have proven it to be just that.


Elon. does. not. make. cars. Elon. does. not. build. rockets.

His strength is leading and believing people who do. Lately however, he’s shown he is not mentally fit for that role. He’s on a crusade more for personal reasons than altruism.

His past accomplishments have been seeing opportunities in failing products that seemed impossible. We're not talking about moonshot startups that really don’t affect a ton of people if they fail.

We’re talking about long established programs that are helping people or keeping people alive. He has ZERO experience with managing this.

I’m just as in favor of cutting bureaucracy as anyone else but I assure you the people making these decisions are not interested in cutting bureaucracy, they’re the ones who created it.


Like idk how long I need to hear about all the great things in tech he’s done when I see his handiwork in an actual tech company over at X. Maybe he was a grifter all along?


> The presumption of course is that everything Elon Musk is doing is stupid

Not stupid. Evil.

The man took pleasure in gutting a major pillar in the world's fight against tuberculosis[1]. This is mass murder, and it's just one of the ways they're causing mass death, likely in the millions over the years to come.

"Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities," said Voltaire. Musk operated one of the biggest misinformation machines in history, got unchecked power of the US government, and now he's moved on to the atrocities phase.

[1] https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/tuberculosis/usaid-funding-freeze...


> The presumption of course is that everything Elon Musk is doing is stupid

Really? My perception is that everything I've seen him do is on its face stupid, even though my perception was that he might do useful things.

Let's take just one data point: he stood up and smirked that he fired everyone working on Ebola response, and of course that was a mistake. Yet those people are still fired. Do you have any counterexamples where he did something not stupid?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: