Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That's actually a really important change that they need to make. If you are trying to raise $5,000 to make 200 widgets by hand, and suddenly your project takes off and you get $500,000 in pledges, then as much as everyone would like to say "that's a great problem to have!", well, it's not.

This point is counterintuitive but here it is: Assuming that there are relatively rigid time constraints, you might be able to make a profit at 200 units, and a profit at 200,000 units, but not at 20,000 units. This is because there are thresholds where you suddenly have to invest in infrastructure, and setting up infrastructure fast is particularly expensive.

If you're raising capital to produce your widgets, you can lay out a business plan and predict with reasonable certainty that you need to sell X widgets before you can break even. You present that to investors and they decide if they think you can sell X widgets.

On Kickstarter, you are implying a fantasy claim of arbitrary linear production scaling that says "I need $25/widget and I will make however many everyone wants!" And hell, that doesn't even work for selling commodities.

So what the model should be for people starting a business selling a tech product is that they say "We're developing a prototype, and if you pledge $X you can get a prototype". Then limit that to a small production run and raise enough money so everyone can involved can quit their job. Now they have time to look for investors, and a great proof of concept that the idea is marketable.



Well, that's actually possible. You can limit the number of backers for any pledge level. So you can have a maximum of 50 supporters backing you to receive a "foo" and another number of "bars" for a different price.

So the usual place where you see an unlimited number of backers is for digital products. See the Amanda Palmer or the Planetary Annihilation: They had limits on any backing that required a physical or personalized goods, but unlimited pledges for digital-only pledges - and there the assumption of "the more I sell, the more I gain" holds true.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: