Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> As I noted in the comment,

Piece of free PR advice: this is fine in a nerd fight, but don't do this in comments that represent a company. Just repeat the relevant information.



Fair feedback, edited!


Piece of free advice towards a better civilisation: people who didn't even read the comment they're replying to shouldn't be rewarded for their laziness.


I read his comment and still replied. I think his claim that nobody reads thinking blocks and that thinking blocks increase latency is nonsense. I am not going to figure out which settings I need to enable because after reading this thread I cancelled my subscription and switched over to Codex. Because I had the exact same experience as many in this thread.

Also what is that "PR advice"—he might as well wear a suit. This is absolutely a nerd fight.


Alright, I just tested that setting and it doesn't work.

https://i.imgur.com/MYsDSOV.png

I tested because I was porting memories from Claude Code to Codex, so I might as well test. I obviously still have subscription days remaining.

There is another comment in this thread linking a GitHub issue that discusses this. The GitHub issue this whole HN submission is about even says that Anthropic hides thinking blocks.


How are you porting over your memories, skills, commands (codex doesn't have commands).


I didn't use commands. I only used rules, memories, and skills. I asked Codex to read rules and memories from where Claude Code stores them on the filesystem and merge them into `AGENTS.md` and this actually works better because Anthropic prompts Claude Code to write each memory to a separate file, so you end up having a main MEMORY.md that acts as a kind of directory that lists each individual memory with its file name and brief description, hoping that Claude Code will read them, but the problem is that Claude Code never does. This is the same problem[0] that Vercel had with skills I believe. Skills are easy to port because they appear to use the same format, so you can just do `mv ~/.claude/skills ~/.codex/skills` (or `.agents/skills`).

[0]: https://vercel.com/blog/agents-md-outperforms-skills-in-our-...


What I was pointing out in my comment about the PR advice is that someone responding from a corporation to customers should be providing information to help the customer, nothing more.

Customers may want to fight - you seem to be providing an example - but representatives shouldn't take the bait.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: