Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I doubt Google is that dumb.

The estimate without quotes for "PS4 blue light of death" is 34M. For "Xbox One blue light of death" is 2.7M.

Although requesting the highest page (990) shows ~288 pages, so estimates are probably not that accurate.



Of course Google is not that dumb. If you don't put quotes in then it will return results that have any of the terms. They do this because they are an advertising company and so it is better to have lots of SRPs returned than none.

What you are doing by not using quotes is dumb.


If you search Google with a quoted string, you will receive only results with a string of those words, in the order specified.

However, if you do not quote the string, Google still searches for all non-common words, but they can be distributed variously around the document. Thus, the white space between search terms can be considered to be an 'and' construct.


the white space between search terms can be considered to be an 'and' construct

No it can't.

Google used to support + prefix on search terms to ensure they appeared on the pages in the results, but that was removed because of Google Plus. Now, to ensure that your query returns results that contain all the words searched for, you need to quote them individually.

https://www.google.com/search?q="PS4"+"blue"+"light"+"of"+"d... returns about 1.5 million results. A scan of the 10th page shows that many of them talk about other lights of death, and happen to also mention PS4 and "blue".


There is also the "allintext:" modifier. Any words after that are searched for verbatim, not even stemming (which is applied to words in quotes).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: